Great post! And a nice balance to today’s uncritical hagiographies.
Complex systems exhibit path dependence and attractor basins, and the law, society and economy is perhaps the most complex system in the universe.
Acknowledging this forces us to give up the notion that any set of rules and constraints will reliably produce a good outcome.
One must have rules, but one must acknowledge that the creation of an institution is simply the start of its eventual corruption. The dynamics of the system will always discover its holes, and the basin will be inhabited.
I appreciate that Posner cared enough to look deeply, and that he was wise enough to understand that what he believed once did not hold.
Thanks, this connects to something I’ve been working on formally. In a paper on fairness governance I argue that institutions don’t converge on a stable rule. They rotate among procedural, performance, and representational commitments as information arrives at different times: neutrality is judged before outcomes exist, efficiency once they’re observable, and distributive effects only after patterns build up. So I’d put it a little differently than “the start of its eventual corruption.” Even an honest institution gets pushed off its rule, because it’s judged on information that didn’t exist when the rule was chosen.
Your basin point is where it connects to Posner. Cycling only happens if long-run harm actually reaches whoever evaluates the rule. When the people bearing that harm can’t get back into the system, the information never arrives, and the institution settles into a basin and stays there. The drug war is a basin, not a cycle.
Great post! And a nice balance to today’s uncritical hagiographies.
Complex systems exhibit path dependence and attractor basins, and the law, society and economy is perhaps the most complex system in the universe.
Acknowledging this forces us to give up the notion that any set of rules and constraints will reliably produce a good outcome.
One must have rules, but one must acknowledge that the creation of an institution is simply the start of its eventual corruption. The dynamics of the system will always discover its holes, and the basin will be inhabited.
I appreciate that Posner cared enough to look deeply, and that he was wise enough to understand that what he believed once did not hold.
Thanks, this connects to something I’ve been working on formally. In a paper on fairness governance I argue that institutions don’t converge on a stable rule. They rotate among procedural, performance, and representational commitments as information arrives at different times: neutrality is judged before outcomes exist, efficiency once they’re observable, and distributive effects only after patterns build up. So I’d put it a little differently than “the start of its eventual corruption.” Even an honest institution gets pushed off its rule, because it’s judged on information that didn’t exist when the rule was chosen.
Your basin point is where it connects to Posner. Cycling only happens if long-run harm actually reaches whoever evaluates the rule. When the people bearing that harm can’t get back into the system, the information never arrives, and the institution settles into a basin and stays there. The drug war is a basin, not a cycle.